
Legendary Indian cricketer Sunil Gavaskar believes only the team’s selectors can decide the futures of under-fire senior players like Rohit Sharma and Virat Kohli:
“It actually all depends on the selectors. I’m not a good reader of the crystal ball, because in Indian cricket, nobody can read a crystal ball. That is a fact. But the contributions which were expected have not come,” Gavaskar said during a recent interview.
Rohit and Virat did not have a great year-end performance in Tests, especially during the New Zealand defeat and first four Border-Gavaskar Trophy 2024/25 games.
Gavaskar Fingers Top-Order Batters as Major Culprits of India’s Test Woes
The veteran believes India’s middle and lower-order are not to blame for their current Test issues. He singles out the top-order as ineffective for India so far, saying batters like Virat and Rohit have not produced expected performances:
“I don’t think it’s a lower-order problem. It’s the top order that has to contribute. So, I mean, the seniors have not really made the contribution that they should have and all that they had to do was to bat out today and live to fight another day in Sydney,” Gavaskar added.
Sunil Gavaskar on Nitish Reddy as a Test All-Rounder
Ideal long-term player for India in whites
Gavaskar believes 21-year-old all-rounder Nitish Kumar Reddy can be a perfect long-time option for the Men in Blue Test team:
“The Melbourne Test brought to the fore one of the brightest young stars in Indian cricket, Nitish Kumar Reddy. He came to the attention of the Indian cricket fans with his performances for the (Sunrisers) Hyderabad franchise in the IPL.”
Gavaskar credits BCCI selectors with Reddy’s successful Test stint
The veteran gave credit to the Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI) selectors for spotting Reddy’s undeniable talent early:
“And while he [Reddy] had not done much at the first-class level, it’s a credit to Ajit Agarkar and his fellow selectors to have seen enough to pitchfork him into the Test arena,” he said.
Reddy’s performance during the Perth Test won Gavaskar over, and the veteran believes India’s chances for success with the youngster can only get better:
“In his debut Test match in Perth itself, it became evident that here’s a cricketer who could read situations and play accordingly. With every subsequent Test match, that impression of a good ‘cricketing head’ on his shoulders began to get stronger and stronger,” Gavaskar added.
Gavaskar believes Nitish is a great replacement for senior all-rounder Hardik Pandya judging from his abilities at such a young age:
“Ever since the unavailability of Hardik Pandya for Test cricket, India has been looking for an all-rounder who can bowl medium pace and bat as well. Reddy’s bowling is still a work in progress, but as a batter, he is definitely better than Pandya was around the same time,” Gavaskar concluded.
Don’t Compare Virat to Rohit – Sanjay Manjrekar
Former Team India batsman Sanjay Manjrekar believes that it is unfair to assess Virat Kohli and Rohit Sharma using the same metrics. The veteran believes Kohli deserves a “longer rope” compared to his under-fire compatriot:
“I must say there is no comparison between Rohit Sharma and Virat Kohli as Test batters. Virat Kohli is right up there. He’s a great Test batter and Rohit Sharma is a good Test batter. Rohit’s white-ball batting great. So Virat Kohli obviously deserves a longer rope. It’s not so much about Virat Kohli. I want to know what the batting coach of India is doing. We can’t solve the obvious problem of such a fine player. Enough has been said about Virat Kohli, we just have to leave him alone,” Manjrekar said.
Rohit could only manage 164 runs from September to December 2024 across Test matches. Manjrekar believes the team hierarchy has vital roles to play towards charting the futures of India’s senior top-order batters:
“It’s not really up to Rohit Sharma. If you look at how the protocol and the hierarchy of team selection is, the chairman of selectors, he has the decision to make. He has the power to do what’s best for Indian cricket, so it’s not so much about Rohit Sharma himself, you know, deciding what should be the future. The chairman of the selector has that power. That’s with Rohit and he does look down in the doldrums. Virat Kohli is a different issue altogether” Manjrekar said.
Other Veterans Criticize India’s Senior Top-Order Batters
Former cricketer stars and coaches like Ravi Shastri, Justin Langer, Atul Wassan, and others have come out to fault the contribution and leadership of India’s top-order batters in recent weeks. The growing concern of veterans across cricketing nations is a worrying sign that India’s Test cricket may face a significant decline in coming series.
